Paradise Lost: How Ecotourism and Capitalism Poisoned Costa Rica
From Untamed Wilderness to Commercialized Chaos: The Hidden Truth Behind the "Happiest Place on Earth"
Ah, Costa Rica—once a land of untamed beauty and rustic charm. The year was 1990, and I found myself in a wild paradise. Dirt roads wound through what would become some of the world’s ritziest famous eco-resorts. It was still a place where bus drivers doubled as makeshift mechanics, hammering away at their engines on the side of the road. But beneath the surface of this seemingly idyllic land lurked the ever-present danger of machete-wielding robbers targeting our fancy cameras. No cell phones, no Google Maps—just guidebooks and a sense of adventure.
Back then, Tortuguero (the turtle destination) was a mere scientific outpost with ranger stations, and the Osa Peninsula was nearly inaccessible—both now are burdened by hordes of cheap hostels and overpriced hotel/condos. Yet just two decades ago, you could camp on any beach you fancied, and nature seemed to ooze from every corner. Fast forward to 2009, and the cracks in this paradise were already showing. Fish in the Caribbean were scarce, dirt roads were paved, and yoga retreats were popping up like a viral infestation. Sloths were more common on T-shirts than in trees, and ecotourism had been distorted by the plague of capitalism and gluttony. North Americans and Europeans flocked in, convinced they were saving the Earth—or so they thought.
The once quaint and distant airport had become a bustling hub, yet San Jose's directions remained a cryptic puzzle of landmarks and vague instructions. "Walk past Dona Maria’s market, turn left at the cow, then right under the full moon." Charming? Maybe. But it softened the harshness of a city that soon lost its musical soul. The marimba music and hanging fern baskets of the Grande Hotel were replaced by jazz and brunch—corporatized and sanitized.
Poverty in Costa Rica hides well, masked by the tourists who rarely interact with the locals. The struggles of affording an apartment or finding decent work are stories left untold to the ecotourists. San Jose by night was a scene straight out of Blade Runner, with barren streets and shuttered services—a far cry from what could be a state of the art capital of sustainability.
Costa Ricans, or Ticos, pride themselves on their supposed lack of corruption, and are quick to point fingers at more violent neighbors like Nicaragua. But look closer, and you'll see dishonesty, fraud, and chaos lurking behind the palm fronds. A friend studying cultural anthropology once explained that the absence of a military had overly pacified the population, preventing any revolutionary spirit. Ticos don't like to fight, he proclaimed, at least not publicly. Even a politician, I spoke with, admitted that Costa Ricans have two faces—the one they show the world and the one they hide at home—where violence is abundant in the macho society.
And then there's the tale of my small pueblo, where I set up an arts and ecology center. Once upon a time, there was just a lone constable—yes, a word from the old days—often found napping in front of an old building. The broom closet-sized jail seemed more like a set piece. But within a few years, the police presence ramped up, and bogus checkpoints started appearing, harassing the poorest who couldn't afford a title for their motorcycles or a day off work to get a license. The rural bus service was abysmal, and the market for used motorcycles was a corrupt game everyone knew about.
Then came the machine guns. In this ridiculously small village, military police checkpoints—don’t say military, they abolished that, right? —became the norm. I once asked fellow bus passengers if they were okay with the cops and their machine guns. The timid smiles in response were telling—the emperor had no clothes, and the arrival of a militarized state was apparent with facism not far behind.
So, yeah, I loved Costa Rica once. It felt like one of the happiest and safest places on Earth. But tourism and U.S. influence, with their geopolitical games, have taken their toll. The result? A country increasingly weakened by corruption and injustice, with its precious biospheres under threat. And the ecotourists? Blinders on, they sip their margaritas and say, "Pura vida." Cheers to that
.help support our film,
Cries of a Jaguar
subscribe!